Home Warranty Exclusions (What’s Not Covered) | Top Home Warranty Reviews

TopHomeWarrantyReviews.com

Home Warranty Exclusions (What’s Not Covered)

The fine print most people skip — explained in plain English.

Why Exclusions Matter

Every home warranty company has a long list of **what’s not covered**. Most complaints online come from people who never saw those exclusions before a claim.

        Key idea: A home warranty can save you thousands — but only if you know
        the limits and play inside the rules. This page explains the exclusions you’ll see
        across almost every company.
      

For what is covered, see our Home Warranty Coverage Guide .

1. Pre-Existing Conditions

If something was already broken or clearly failing **before** your coverage started, it’s usually excluded.

Known issues noted on an inspection
Systems that never worked after move-in
Long-term leaks or recurring problems

If an inspector or contractor could reasonably see the issue before the start date, the warranty company may call it “pre-existing” and deny the claim.

2. Lack of Maintenance

Home warranties expect “normal maintenance.” If a failure is caused by neglect, the claim can be denied. Examples:

Never changing A/C filters
Ignoring obvious leaks
Not flushing a water heater as required

You don’t need to be perfect, but you should do basic upkeep and keep receipts or simple notes when possible.

3. Damage From Events (Not Wear and Tear)

Home warranties only cover **wear and tear**, not sudden external events. These are almost always excluded and should go to homeowners insurance instead:

Storm, hail, wind, or lightning damage
Fire, smoke, or explosion
Flooding or water from outside the home
Theft or vandalism

If a tree hits your A/C or a storm rips off part of your roof, that’s homeowners insurance — not a home warranty.

American Home Coverage - Over 50 years of industry experience 59,746 Reviews

Excellent 9.9

4. Cosmetic Issues Only

Home warranties care about **function**, not looks. Common exclusions:

Dents, scratches, or discoloration on appliances
Broken handles, knobs, or trim that don’t affect function
Stained tubs, showers, or sinks

If the system or appliance still works, cosmetic problems are almost never covered.

5. Code Upgrades, Permits & Bringing Things “Up to Code”

Many older homes have systems that don’t meet current building codes. If a repair requires upgrades to meet today’s code, you may be responsible for:

Extra parts to meet new code
Permit and inspection fees
Access work (opening walls, concrete, etc.) beyond what’s covered

Some contracts include a small allowance for code or permits, but it’s usually limited. Always check the “limits and coverage” section of your contract.

6. Roof Exclusions

When roof coverage is offered, it’s usually limited to **patching active leaks** over the **occupied living area**. Common exclusions:

Full roof replacement
Missing or worn shingles
Metal, tile, or flat roofs (often excluded)
Patios, porches, detached structures
Gutters, downspouts, skylights, chimneys

If you see “roof leak coverage” in a brochure, it almost always means patching a small area — not replacing the entire roof.

7. Unusual or Specialty Items

Standard home warranty plans focus on typical systems and appliances. Items often excluded unless specifically added as an option:

Pool and spa equipment
Well and septic systems
Second refrigerators or wine coolers
Solar equipment
Guest houses or detached buildings

If you care about one of these, look for it in the add-ons section when you compare plans.

8. Improper Installation, Undersized Systems & Misuse

Home warranties usually exclude problems caused by:

Incorrect installation or wiring
Systems that are too small for the home (undersized)
Using a system beyond normal residential use
DIY modifications that break code

If an inspector says “this was installed wrong from day one,” the warranty company will usually call it an installation issue, not wear and tear.

9. Most Common Reasons Claims Get Denied

Across almost all companies, these are the top denial reasons:

Pre-existing issue (problem started before the contract).
Lack of basic maintenance (no filter changes, etc.).
Damage from events (storm, flood, fire).
Non-covered part failed (like a vent or cosmetic part).
Item not listed as covered anywhere in the contract.

        Tip: When something breaks, take photos of the problem,
        keep receipts for any basic maintenance, and report the failure as soon as
        possible. This can help if there’s a dispute.
      

How to Read a Home Warranty Contract

Contracts are boring, but reading just a few sections will save you a lot of pain later:

“Covered items” list for your plan.
“Not covered” or “Exclusions” section.
Coverage limits and dollar caps per item and per term.
Definitions for “normal wear and tear” and “pre-existing.”

If you’re comparing providers, put two contracts side-by-side and compare limits and exclusions, not just monthly price.

Exclusions FAQ

Why didn’t my warranty cover my problem?

Most denials come down to one of three things: the item wasn’t covered, the issue was pre-existing, or the damage was caused by something like a storm or flood (which is insurance, not warranty).

Can I fight a denied claim?

You can usually request a re-review, submit photos or maintenance records, and ask for clarity on the specific contract clause. But if the contract is clear, the decision often stands.

Are all companies this strict?

Every company has exclusions, but some are more flexible and easier to work with than others. That’s why we rank providers on overall value and claim experience — not just price.

Next Steps: Choose a Plan That Works for You

Now that you know what’s not covered, the next step is comparing real plans so you get the best mix of coverage, price, and limits.

View Best Home Warranty Companies 2025 Are Home Warranties Worth It?

American Home Coverage - Over 50 years of industry experience 59,746 Reviews

Excellent 9.9